The case rests on three things: distance, direction and difference.
Close enough to share a day, far enough to feel like two trips
Winslow to the park is roughly an hour of interstate, with Holbrook in between as the fuel, food and fallback town. That is close enough that a morning in Winslow and an afternoon in the park is a relaxed plan, not a stunt, and far enough that the two halves never blur. You breakfast in a railroad hotel dining room and you are looking at 225 million year old stone trees before lunch has worn off. Verdict: if you are driving I-40 past one of them, skipping the other is the only wrong plan.
The loop the Park Service already designed
Petrified Forest has two entrances and one road between them, and the National Park Service tells eastbound I-40 travelers exactly what to do: exit at Holbrook, Exit 285, drive 19 miles south on Highway 180 to the south entrance, drive the 28 mile park road north, and rejoin I-40 at Exit 311. Starting from Winslow, that advice becomes a perfect loop. East on I-40 to Holbrook, south into the park, north through it, then west on I-40 straight back to Winslow. Westbound travelers simply run it in reverse, entering at Exit 311 and exiting toward Holbrook. Verdict: enter south, exit north, from Winslow. The park reads in order and the drive home is the short leg.
A song and a stone forest
Winslow gives the trip its story: Route 66, the Santa Fe Railway, a Fred Harvey hotel and a lyric everyone in the car can sing. The park gives it scale: the Painted Desert, petroglyphs, a pueblo, and logs that were trees when dinosaurs were new. Either one alone can feel thin to a skeptic, Winslow too quick, the park too quiet. Together they balance. The town warms you up for the landscape, and the landscape earns the town its place on the map. Verdict: sell the trip to your travel partners as both. It is an easier yes, and it happens to be true.


