Who should not do Lower
Operators are blunt here, and so is this guide. Lower's stairs and ladders rule out visitors with mobility, balance, knee, hip or back problems, and Ken's Tours ticket terms state the tour is not allowed during pregnancy. Strollers are banned in both canyons, and child carrier rules differ by operator: Dixie's has toddlers ride in a hiking backpack or wrap, other operators set their own rules, so check yours before booking with a baby. Upper's canyon floor is flat sand, but the tour is not wheelchair accessible either: the floor is deep sand, the exit climbs stairs and a ramp, and the ride between Page and the canyon entrance is in an open truck over a washboard wash. Anyone who cannot do Lower can almost always do Upper, and should. Verdict: mobility decides this comparison before price or photos get a vote. Upper for limited mobility, Lower only for the sure footed.
The rules that surprise people
Both canyons run on Navajo Nation rules, enforced kindly and completely. No tripods, monopods or selfie sticks on sightseeing tours. Bags: Dixie's bans all bags in Lower, including clear ones, and Upper operators set their own bag rules, most of them strict, so check your confirmation. Video: Ken's bars video recording in Lower, and Dixie's bars GoPros and action cameras outright. Phones and handheld cameras are welcome, and guides are famously good at taking your photo for you. Check in 30 to 45 minutes early at the operator's Page location; late arrivals are treated as no shows, and tickets are generally nonrefundable. And the clock has a trap in Page: the town does not observe daylight saving, the Navajo Nation does, operators run on Page time, and phones flip near the boundary. Trust your confirmation, not your phone. Verdict: travel light, arrive early, and let the guide shoot the group photo. The rules are the price of a canyon this well kept.
When each canyon feels emptiest
Upper at midday in beam season is the most crowded slot in Page, and it is also the only slot with beams. That is the trade, stated plainly. Upper's first and last departures of the day run calmer and dimmer. Lower spreads its crowds better across the day, and its first morning tours and late afternoon tours feel noticeably thinner than the late morning peak. Shoulder months help both: late February, early March before spring break, and late October run the same canyons with a fraction of the summer flow, at winter light in Upper and fine color in Lower. Verdict: if crowds are your top concern, book Lower early on a weekday, or look at Canyon X below before you book either famous name.
Antelope Canyon X: the local answer
There is a third slot canyon in the same system, and it exists for people who read this far and winced at the crowds. Antelope Canyon X, run by Taadidiin Tours, lists its hiking tour at $47 per adult plus the $15 permit, about $62 all in, about 90 minutes for two canyon sections, with smaller groups and stairs down into the canyon as the trade for the lower price. No beams are promised, the light is the reflected color kind, and the operator's whole pitch is fewer people. It is the right call for a second canyon day, a tight budget, or anyone whose trip is about standing in sculpted stone rather than collecting the famous frame. Verdict: X is not a consolation prize. For a lot of visitors it is the best hour in Page, precisely because it is not the famous one.

